Hot Wheels accused of stealing Icon FJ40 Baja design [UPDATE]

June 6, 2012 by · Leave a Comment 

Filed under: Classics , SUV , Government/Legal , Toyota , Toys/Games , Specialty , Design/Style , Off-Road In a perfect world, all of our favorite companies would get along merrily. But sadly, we do not live in a perfect world. Icon , the company behind some of the most lust-worthy vintage off-roaders and street machines in existence, is accusing toymaker Mattel of stealing the FJ40 Baja Edition design for a Hot Wheels die cast toy. According to the most recent Icon newsletter, Hot Wheels lifted a photo of the heavily modified FJ40, slathered a quick Photoshop job over the image and called it a day. Except Mattel reportedly never asked Icon for permission to use the image or the vehicle design in its marketing or products. Icon reportedly reached out to Mattel to no avail. That’s about when the custom builder turned to its lawyers, prompting the attorney for Hot Wheels to say the company wanted to settle the matter out of court. A month went by before Icon once again tried to reach out. Mattel allegedly dismissed Icon, effectively challenging the smaller company to try to sue the toy monolith if Icon thought it stood a chance. Hot Wheels hasn’t spoken out on the issue.

Filed under: , , , , , , ,

Hot Wheels Icon FJ40 Baja Edition

In a perfect world, all of our favorite companies would get along merrily. But sadly, we do not live in a perfect world. Icon, the company behind some of the most lust-worthy vintage off-roaders and street machines in existence, is accusing toymaker Mattel of stealing the FJ40 Baja Edition design for a Hot Wheels die cast toy. According to the most recent Icon newsletter, Hot Wheels lifted a photo of the heavily modified FJ40, slathered a quick Photoshop job over the image and called it a day. Except Mattel reportedly never asked Icon for permission to use the image or the vehicle design in its marketing or products.

Icon reportedly reached out to Mattel to no avail. That’s about when the custom builder turned to its lawyers, prompting the attorney for Hot Wheels to say the company wanted to settle the matter out of court. A month went by before Icon once again tried to reach out. Mattel allegedly dismissed Icon, effectively challenging the smaller company to try to sue the toy monolith if Icon thought it stood a chance.

Hot Wheels hasn’t spoken out on the issue. With five of the tiny diecasts on our desk and five hundred in a box downstairs, we’ve had a life-long relationship with the toymaker. But that doesn’t excuse the reported bully tactics. Here’s hoping this one gets squared away sooner rather than later. Check out an excerpt from the Icon newsletter below.

UPDATE: Designer, Founder and Owner of Icon 4×4, Jonathan Ward, released the following statement to Autoblog.

The issue is that they stole the image, took many unique design details and trade dress elements unique to ICON, and used the Federally filed Trademark without permission, then tried to play bully to make the issue disappear. They offered us $1,500 dollars to go away. I know big fish like to dine on little fish, but I do not feel this is good business ethics. I reached out to HW about six months before they released the range of models and launched the series with my image on their website. After our cease and desist letter, they promptly removed the image. They never replied to my email, which had included that very same copy protected image. Also, I am not a rich man. My wife and I built this brand from nothing but sweat and tears. I am proud to employ skilled American workers and provide them a great place to work with fine benefits, and we take pride to build our vehicles with the best possible content. It adds up and they are expensive. I wish they were cheaper but we build the best we can, and then sell it at a fair and reasonable business margin. Plenty of companies start with a price target, then build to meet that. A lot of design and quality value gets lost that way.

– JW ICON

UPDATE 2: Hooniverse has received a response from Hot Wheels.

Continue reading Hot Wheels accused of stealing Icon FJ40 Baja design [UPDATE]

Hot Wheels accused of stealing Icon FJ40 Baja design [UPDATE] originally appeared on Autoblog on Tue, 05 Jun 2012 19:00:00 EST. Please see our terms for use of feeds.

Permalink

About Toyota

Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!

Tweeter button Facebook button Youtube button